The Vanishing Hitchhiker: Wrong Turn
The Drive
The rain hammered Eric's windshield like angry fists, each drop exploding into fractals of light against the headlight beams. Highway 35 stretched endlessly ahead, a black ribbon cutting through the Texas borderlands where desert scrub and mesquite trees huddled together in the darkness. The digital clock on his dashboard glowed 12:17 AM.
Almost home, he thought, gripping the steering wheel tighter as another gust of wind rocked his Honda Civic. The visit to Nuevo Laredo had run late—his tía Carmen's birthday party stretching past midnight with endless plates of tamales and family stories. Now he was paying for it, driving through a storm that seemed to have materialized from nowhere.
His abuela's voice echoed in his memory, the same warning she'd given him every time he made this drive: "Mijo, los espíritus caminan por las carreteras en la noche. Never stop for strangers when the moon is dark. Some souls are still walking, looking for a way home."
Eric had always dismissed them as old-world superstition. But out here, with lightning illuminating dead trees and rain turning everything into shifting shadows, those words felt heavier.
That’s when he saw her.
A figure stood on the shoulder of the road about fifty yards ahead, pale against the storm-dark landscape. As his headlights swept over her, Eric could make out a young woman in a white dress, soaked through, her dark hair plastered to her skull. One arm was raised, thumb extended—the universal gesture every driver recognized.
Eric's foot moved toward the brake pedal, then hesitated. Every rational part of his brain screamed warnings: Middle of nowhere. Midnight. Storm. Strange woman. His abuela's voice joined the chorus: Don't stop.
But she was so small against the vastness of the night, so desperately alone. Water ran down her bare arms like tears. She couldn't be more than twenty-five, and she was barefoot on the asphalt.
What if she's hurt? What if she'd been in an accident and needed help? What kind of person would he be if he just drove past?
The Honda's brakes hissed softly as Eric pulled onto the shoulder. Through his passenger window, he could see her more clearly now. She was beautiful in an otherworldly way, with sharp cheekbones and eyes that seemed too large for her face. Her dress clung to her slight frame, and despite the storm, she stood perfectly still, as if the wind couldn't touch her.
Eric rolled down the window. "¿Estás bien? Are you okay?"
She approached the car with measured steps, water dripping from her dress. Up close, her skin had an almost translucent quality, and her lips were the color of old roses.
"I need a ride," she said, her voice barely above a whisper but somehow perfectly clear despite the storm's roar. "Please."
Eric hesitated for another heartbeat, his hand frozen on the door lock. Every instinct screamed danger, but those wide, dark eyes held such sadness. Such need.
He unlocked the passenger door.
She slid into the seat with fluid grace, bringing with her the smell of rain and something else—something earthy and old, like wet stones. Water puddled immediately on his cloth seats, but she seemed unbothered by her soaked condition. She stared straight ahead through the windshield, hands folded in her lap.
"Where do you need to go?" Eric asked, putting the car back in drive.
For a long moment, she didn't answer. Eric was beginning to think she hadn't heard him when she finally spoke.
"1247 Esperanza Street. Just past town."
Eric frowned. He'd lived in Laredo his entire life, and he couldn't place that address. "Which part of town? I might need directions."
A small smile played at the corners of her mouth. "I'll show you the way."
The Hitchhiker
Eric pulled back onto the highway, windshield wipers beating steadily against the rain. He glanced at his passenger, who sat motionless beside him, staring ahead with unblinking eyes. Water still dripped from her hair, but she made no attempt to dry herself or adjust the air conditioning that Eric had turned up for her comfort.
"So what were you doing out there?" he asked, trying to fill the uncomfortable silence. "Car trouble?"
She didn't respond immediately, and when she did, her voice carried a strange, distant quality. "I was waiting."
"Waiting for what?"
"For someone to stop."
The answer sent an inexplicable chill down Eric's spine, but he pushed the feeling away. She was probably in shock, maybe hypothermic. People said strange things when they were scared and cold.
They drove in silence for several miles, the storm gradually lessening but not disappearing entirely. As they approached the outskirts of Laredo, Eric expected her to give him more specific directions, but she remained quiet until they reached the first major intersection.
"Turn right here," she said suddenly.
Eric looked at the street sign: Farm Road 1472. It led away from town, deeper into the desert. "Are you sure? I thought you said just past town."
"This way is quicker."
He hesitated, but she seemed so certain. Maybe there was a subdivision out that way he didn't know about. The city had been growing, sprawling outward into what used to be ranch land.
Eric turned right.
The road was darker than the highway, with fewer streetlights and no painted center line. Desert vegetation pressed closer on both sides, and the rain had turned the unpaved shoulders into muddy streams. After about ten minutes of driving, Eric pulled out his phone to check the GPS.
The screen showed their location as a blank area—just gray space where the map should be. No roads, no landmarks, nothing.
"That's weird," he muttered, tapping the screen. "GPS isn't working."
The woman beside him smiled wider. "Technology fails out here sometimes. The old roads don't like to be found."
Eric shot her a questioning look, but she was staring ahead again, completely calm. Something about her stillness bothered him. Normal people fidgeted, shifted in their seats, looked around. She sat like a statue, hands perfectly folded, breathing so quietly he couldn't even hear it over the engine.
"Left at the next intersection," she said.
Eric squinted through the windshield. He couldn't see any intersection ahead, just more empty road stretching into darkness. But as they crested a small hill, an unmarked crossroads appeared, as if materializing from the night itself.
Perdido
He turned left onto an even smaller road, this one barely wide enough for two cars. The pavement was cracked and buckled, and weeds grew through the gaps. Mailboxes appeared sporadically along the roadside, but Eric couldn't see any houses behind them—just empty lots where structures should have been.
A road sign flashed in his headlights: "Welcome to Perdido - Population 847." Eric had never heard of Perdido, and he thought he knew every small town within fifty miles of Laredo.
"I've never been through here before," he said.
"Most people haven't."
They passed a billboard advertising "Espejo's 24-Hour Diner - Best Coffee in Three Counties!" with a cheerful cartoon cup waving from the faded sign. But when Eric looked for the diner, he saw only empty desert and a crumbling concrete foundation.
"Where exactly is this Esperanza Street?" he asked, a growing uneasiness creeping into his voice.
"We're almost there," she replied, and for the first time since getting in the car, she turned to look at him directly.
Her eyes were completely black.
Eric blinked hard, certain he was seeing things wrong in the dim dashboard light, but when he looked again, her eyes had returned to their normal dark brown. Had he imagined it? The stress of the late night and the storm must be getting to him.
The road curved sharply to the right, and suddenly they were driving through what looked like the remains of a town. Empty storefronts lined both sides of the street, their windows dark and broken. A church steeple rose against the storm clouds, but its proportions seemed wrong—too tall, too narrow.
Eric's gas gauge, which had shown nearly half a tank when he picked up the hitchhiker, now flickered erratically between full and empty. The radio, tuned to his favorite station, had dissolved into static that almost sounded like whispered voices.
"Turn here," the woman said, pointing to a street Eric couldn't see until his headlights swept over the sign: Esperanza Street, exactly as she'd said. But the letters seemed to shift and blur when he looked directly at them.
His hands were shaking now, and not from the cold.
Esperanza Street
The moment Eric turned onto Esperanza Street, the rain stopped. Not gradually, but all at once, as if someone had turned off a faucet. The sudden silence was deafening after hours of constant drumming on the roof. Even his windshield wipers seemed too loud as they squeaked across the now-dry glass.
He turned them off and immediately regretted it. The world beyond his headlights had become too still, too quiet. No wind rustled the desert plants. No insects chirped. Even the engine seemed muted, as if the sound was being swallowed by the darkness itself.
The street stretched ahead, but it was unlike any residential road Eric had ever seen. The pavement was perfectly smooth, without painted lines or any kind of marking. Houses—if they could be called that—sat far back from the road, barely visible as geometric shadows against the sky. No lights shone in any windows.
But there were figures.
They stood at regular intervals along the roadside, motionless as mannequins. At first, Eric thought they might be scarecrows or some kind of folk art installation, but as his headlights swept over them, he realized they were people. Men, women, children, all dressed in pale clothing, all standing perfectly straight with their arms at their sides.
All facing the road. Watching.
"What is this place?" Eric whispered, his voice hoarse.
The woman beside him was changing. Her wet dress had somehow dried completely, but more than that, she seemed more solid now, more present, as if she'd been only partially there before and was now fully materializing.
"Home," she said simply.
Eric glanced at the passenger-side window and nearly drove off the road. In the rain-slick glass, the hitchhiker’s reflection was smiling—a wide, hungry grin that split her face from ear to ear. But when he looked directly at her, her expression was serene, almost peaceful.
His phone buzzed. A text message from an unknown number: "Turn around."
Then another: "GO BACK."
And another: "IT'S NOT TOO LATE."
But when Eric looked at his phone screen, it was completely black except for his own reflection staring back at him. And in that reflection, the woman beside him was reaching for the steering wheel.
Eric jerked the phone away and gripped the wheel tighter. The dashboard lights flickered, and the radio crackled with voices calling his name. Eric. Eric. Mijo, turn around. Come home.
They passed a bridge—though Eric couldn't remember seeing any rivers or creeks on the map. The water beneath was black and still, reflecting nothing, as if it absorbed light instead of bouncing it back. The bridge had no railings, just smooth stone that seemed to stretch endlessly in both directions.
"Stop the car," the woman said.
"No." Eric's voice was stronger than he felt. "Tell me where you really want to go, or I'm taking you to the police station."
She laughed, a sound like wind chimes made of bones. "You can't go to the police, Eric. You can't go anywhere. You chose to stop. You chose to pick me up. Now you have to finish the ride."
The Crossing
The road ahead split into three directions, though Eric was certain it had been straight just moments before. His gas gauge spun like a compass searching for north. The temperature display showed impossible readings—sometimes 120 degrees, sometimes -40, sometimes simply displaying symbols he didn't recognize.
In the distance, Eric could see lights. Familiar lights. Street lamps that looked like the ones from his neighborhood, arranged in patterns he recognized. A McDonald's golden arches glowed against the sky, exactly where one should be if this were the main drag in Laredo.
But as they got closer, the details were wrong. The McDonald's building was made of adobe instead of brick. The street lamps cast shadows upward instead of down. And the street signs...
Eric slammed on the brakes.
The green sign ahead read "Calle Oderela" in backward letters, the paint seeming to shift and flow like liquid mercury.
Laredo backward.
They were still moving, though Eric's foot was pressed hard on the brake pedal. The car glided forward as if pulled by invisible hands, tires silent on the impossible pavement.
Eric's world had become a funhouse mirror of everything he knew. They passed Joe's Auto Repair, but the windows were bricked over and grass grew through cracks in the parking lot. The Circle K where he bought his morning coffee stood empty, its sign reading "K Circle" with letters that dripped like melting wax.
His mother's street appeared ahead—Magnolia Drive—but the familiar yellow road sign was printed in reverse, and the houses that should have been there were hollow shells, their windows dark and empty as eye sockets.
"What do you want from me?" Eric demanded, his voice cracking with panic.
The hitchhiker turned to face him fully for the first time since getting in the car. Her features were sharper now, more defined, as if she'd been slightly out of focus before. Her skin had a luminous quality that didn't come from any earthly light.
"I don't want anything," she said, her voice carrying harmonics that made Eric's teeth ache. "You stopped. You offered. In the old places, on the old roads, an offer freely given must be completed. You promised to take me home, Eric Morales."
Eric's blood went cold. He'd never told her his last name.
"My abuela was right," he whispered. "You're not alive."
"I was alive once. We all were." She gestured to the figures still standing along the roadside, now visible in horrifying detail. Their faces were blank, features worn smooth like river stones. "Every person who stopped, who offered help, who ignored the warnings their abuelas gave them. We're all here now. All of us who were too kind for our own good."
Eric saw his family's house ahead, but something was terribly wrong with it. The windows were painted black, and the front door hung open like a screaming mouth. His father's truck sat in the driveway, but the tires were flat and weeds grew through the wheel wells.
"This isn't real," Eric said, but even as he spoke the words, he knew they were hollow. The wheel felt solid in his hands. The seat was warm beneath him. The fear racing through his veins was absolutely, undeniably real.
"It's real," she confirmed. "Just not the real you're used to. You've crossed over, Eric. The moment you stopped for me, the moment you chose compassion over caution, you stepped into our world. The place where the stories your abuela told come from."
They pulled into his family's driveway without Eric steering the car. The engine died on its own, keys still in the ignition. Through the windshield, Eric could see movement in the house—shadows that didn't match anything that should be casting them.
"You shouldn't have stopped," the woman said, her voice now carrying the weight of genuine sadness. "But I'm glad you did. It gets lonely, being the only one flagging down cars. It's nice to have company."
Eric tried to grab the door handle, but his hand passed through it as if it were made of smoke. He lunged for the keys, but they crumbled to dust at his touch.
"Don't fight it," the woman said gently. "Fighting just makes it harder."
She began to fade, becoming translucent, then transparent, then nothing at all. Only a damp spot on the passenger seat remained, and even that was evaporating quickly.
But her voice lingered, seeming to come from everywhere and nowhere: "Welcome home, Eric."
Welcome Home
Eric sat alone in his car in the driveway of a house that looked like home but felt like a tomb. The silence was absolute now—no wind, no insects, no distant highway noise. Even his own breathing seemed muted, as if the air itself was reluctant to carry sound.
He tried the radio. Static filled with whispers in languages he didn't recognize. He tried his phone. The screen showed a single bar of signal, but when he attempted to call his mother, the number rang once and connected to his own voicemail message, played backward.
Slowly, Eric got out of the car. His footsteps made no sound on the concrete driveway. The air smelled of rain and desert flowers and something else—something that reminded him of the funeral home where they'd held services for his grandfather last spring.
Every house on the street was a mirror image of places he knew. Mrs. Rodriguez's blue house with the chain-link fence was there, but the fence was made of bones, and the windows were painted black.
And on every corner, she stood waiting.
The hitchhiker, no longer pale and soaked but radiant and terrible, stood at each intersection with her thumb extended. Dozens of her, hundreds maybe, all wearing the same white dress, all wearing the same patient smile. Some faced north, some south, some east, some west. All waiting for the next car, the next kind soul who would ignore their abuela's warnings.
Eric pulled out his phone one more time, desperate to find some connection to the world he'd left behind. The GPS app opened automatically, showing his location as a perfect circle—a road that curved endlessly back on itself with no beginning and no end. The street name simply read: "The Long Way Home."
In the phone's black screen, a reflection appeared that wasn't his own. The hitchhiker sat in the car behind him, visible in the rearview mirror that he hadn't looked at. She waved at him with the fingers of one hand while the other pointed down the road.
"There's another car coming," her reflection whispered, voice carrying clearly despite coming from the phone's tiny speaker. "A young woman from San Antonio. She's been driving all night, and she's tired. She's going to see me standing there in about ten minutes."
Eric turned around, but the car was empty. When he looked back at his phone, the hitchhiker's reflection smiled wider.
"You could warn her," she continued. "You could try to flag her down, tell her not to stop. But who's going to listen to a stranger on a dark road, especially one who looks as desperate as you do now?"
Eric's reflection in the phone screen was changing. His clothes were becoming pale and shapeless, his features growing indistinct. Soon, he realized, he would look just like the watchers standing along the roadside.
In the distance, Eric could hear the faint sound of an engine approaching. Headlights swept across the horizon, still far away but getting closer.
The hitchhiker's reflection leaned forward conspiratorially. "Or you could help me. Make this easier for her. After all, she's going to end up here either way. At least this way, she'll have a friend when she arrives."
Eric looked at his hands. They were already starting to fade around the edges.
"Almost there," the hitchhiker whispered, and her voice was the last sound Eric heard from the world he used to know.
The headlights grew brighter, and Eric found himself walking toward the road, his thumb extended, wearing a smile that felt too wide for his face. Behind him, the Honda Civic dissolved into mist, as if it had never existed at all.
Somewhere in the real world, a family in Laredo would wake up to find their son never came home from Nuevo Laredo. The police would search Highway 35, finding no trace of Eric or his car. His abuela would light candles and whisper prayers, knowing in her heart what had happened but unable to prove it to a world that had forgotten how to listen to the old warnings.
And on the dark roads between here and there, in the spaces between what is and what should never be, the hitchhikers would continue to wait, thumbs extended, smiles patient and eternal.
After all, there's always another car coming.
Someone else who's too kind for their own good.
Someone else whose abuela warned them never to stop for strangers at night.
Almost there.
Afterword
Have you ever driven a dark road late at night and seen someone standing by the roadside? Did you stop?
The next time you're tempted to help a stranger in the darkness, remember Eric's story. Sometimes kindness comes at a price higher than you're prepared to pay.
© 2025 Karen Cody. All rights reserved. This original story was written exclusively for the Urban Legends, Mystery, and Myth blog. Do not copy, repost, or reproduce without permission. This tale may appear in a future special collection.
Enjoyed this story? Urban Legends, Mystery, and Myth explores the creepiest corners of folklore—from haunted objects and bloodthirsty creatures to chilling historical mysteries. Don't forget to check out last week's Free Story Friday about Bloody Mary.
Want more bite-sized horror? Discover our companion book series, Urban Legends and Tales of Terror, for reimagined fiction inspired by the legends we cover here.
Because some stories don't stay buried.
Comments
Post a Comment